I bought 4 10lb plates and for the most part I'm happy with them.

Paint- Could be better. There's a lot of spots that were touched up and it's very obvious when looking at them. The paint on the lettering is pretty good at least.

Casting- Meh. The holes need lots of filing down before putting them on a barbell or else you'll scratch up the sleeves a lot. There's lots of spots where holes were filled and others where jagged edges were ground down. My biggest issue is one plate has a slight curve to it. It doesn't sit flush against other plates or on a flat surface but oh well.

I knew what I was buying and didn't expect perfect looking calibrated plates. Basically you get what you pay for. At the end of the day they're 10lb iron plates and aren't being entered in a beauty contest. I'll exercise with them and not be afraid of dropping them on the floor.

So I had to jump on these when i saw the price drop to $36 each with prime shipping and Im glad I did! You just cant beat the value at that price point! when I received these the packaging was pretty beat but thats pretty understandable I mean 2 of them even came together in one package Id be choked too if I had to haul a 90lb package around that being said the actual weights themselves were completely undamaged! In my research i found two posted diameters for these plates but the ones I received measure a hair under 17 3/4". My only complaint about these is the outer lip is so small it make one handed carrying a bit of a chore for the fingers but I really dont mind it.

Great quality. As a weight plate, there really aint much it needs to do to meet expectations but to weigh 35 lbss and fit on a barbell. I only took one star away because i already owned a 35lb plate by cap barbell and needed another one to make it a matching pair. I assumed they were all made the same size..however this one was a bout an inch larger in circumference, slightly thinner but still 35 lbs. Therefore my barbell would sit on floor lopsided with these 2 plates on.

These are really nice plates, especially since I bought 5lb plates for $1.99 each! My only gripe is that these were an "add on item" and for some reason, the seller limited buyers from purchasing more than 3 plates! Who uses odd numbers of weight plates (other than using a lone single plate for a leg attachment, weighted dips, or a single dumbbell exercise such as seated tricep extensions)?!?! You need FOUR plates to complete a pair of dumbbells and TWO plates for a barbell/curl bar! Plus the seller wouldn't even let me buy one single plate at full price to complete the set! No big deal, I guess. Bought a single Champion plate to complete my pair of dumbbells.

I've ordered four of these so far and they've all come in decent shape, I only needed to grind down a few sharp edges of paint. The only major problem is each plate varies in weight by 1 to 2 pounds. It's not noticeable when I have them all on the bar, but I imagine it would add up and become annoying if anyone is using a bunch of plates at the same time. The best thing about these plates is the price.