My husband has had a pair of Dockers Kiltie loafers for many years and they wore really well and always looked good. This pair is a replacement since the first pair has finally started to look a little tired and worn. And as amazing as it seems, the style of the new pair looks exactly the same with the same high quality - not many companies have maintained their past quality over all these years!

Please note: this 5* review is made after only wearing the shoes a couple of times. There have been a few other reviews that express concerns about durability. I've only had the shoes a short period, so I can't attest to how well they'll last in the long run.

These are really nice, comfortable loafers. Great for casual wear. I really look forward to wearing the soles off of these shoes :) -- hopefully that will take a long, long time before it happens.

Nice looking casual loafer appropriate for the business casual office. Light shine on the leather. Very comfortable sole and footbed cushioning. The only drawback I encountered was that the back of the shoe lacked padding which rubbed blisters on the back of my ankles the first few times I wrote them.

I ordered the 11W which arrived and was a much tighter and shorter shoe than when I purchased the same shoe a few years ago. I returned this pair and ordered the 11.5W. I was given a credit via Amazon gift card in my account rather, then the replacement pair was billed to my account, using the gift card balance -- a very strange way to do it, but I was not involved in either the credit or the charge back. The replacement pair was a 11.5W box with an 11W shoe in it. Not helpful, so I returned it for refund and sought shoes elsewhere. I received notice that the return has been received, and $1.51 has been credited to my AMEX card. My credit should be $64.19. I have finally located the Contact Us field -- it is there if you dig deep enough -- and reported the issue. We'll see. This is a favorite shoe, but either the shoe has changed or my foot is woefully distorted from what it was a few years ago.

Very, very comfortable. My second day wearing them and they feel like I've wore them for a year - so comfortable. I wear a 10 1/2 and the size is spot on. Fit is perfect. Very happy with these shoes. Recommend.