Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, Smooth 1pk, Gluten Free & Vegan, 26 Ounce Plastic Jar (Smooth, 26 Ounce (Pack of 1))




Key features
- •Proudly made in the USA using only USA grown peanuts
- •Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Vegan Friendly
- •No preservatives or sugars added. One more thing: Oil separation occurs naturally in our peanut butter. Although you don't need to refrigerate Teddie, to slow the oil separation just stir the jar contents, tighten the cap and then place it in the refrigerator.
- •Family owned and operated since 1925
- •Teddie is a true Natural peanut butter, NOT a peanut butter "spread"
Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, Smooth 1pk, Gluten Free & Vegan, 26 Ounce Plastic Jar (Smooth, 26 Ounce (Pack of 1))
List Price: $56.64$50.98DEALYou Save: $5.66 (10%)
Free shippingFree Returns – 30 daysFree Order CancellationSecure Payment2–3 Days DeliveryGet It June 24, 2026In Stock (4)No marketing spamNo account requiredFulfilment by FedEx / Amazon / UPS / ShipwirePayPal / Card Buyer Protection
Customer Reviews
Reviews sourced from verified Amazon purchasers4.4
out of 5
Based on 10 reviews
5★
100%
4★
0%
3★
0%
2★
0%
1★
0%
Teddy is the best, and made in Massachusetts
thershegoesagn•May 3, 2017
Sent to my daughter/grandson in Alabama, they can't get this down there. Teddy is the best, and made in Massachusetts!
Great tasting
Kindle Customer•April 19, 2017
I love this peanut butter. Tastes great and needs little stirring after the first one. I have learned to cut back on other liquids when baking as this is not as thick as store bought regular peanut butter since it does not have the additives
Yum!
Dave•March 24, 2017
Very good peanut butter. I read the reviews thoroughly and understood that there is separation in natural peanut butter. So, I ordered three jar and kept them in the refrigerator as suggest by several reviewers. I take one jar out at a time, about 1 hour prior to use, and use the product, replacing the jar in the refrigerator after each use. I have had not quality issues and love this product. It tastes great and is only 1 sugar per server as compared to 7-8 for "regular" peanut butter.
This is what peanut butter was SUPPOSED to be from day one!
Tom•September 6, 2016
If you even think you like peanut butter, beware. This product is soooo good, you'll kick yourself for not buying the 3-pak right away. Like any really healthy food, it might take you 3-4 minutes to realize this is not Jiff, Skippy, etc. After that you'll be addicted. Yes, it does leave a bit of a sticky residue in your mouth that you're not used to because there are no extra unhealthy oils and crap in the product. Peanuts and some salt. That's it.
Try one jar and you'll kick yourself for not having bought the 3-pak. Trust me. I will never buy any other peanut butter.
Try one jar and you'll kick yourself for not having bought the 3-pak. Trust me. I will never buy any other peanut butter.
All is well that ends well.
CLK•June 20, 2016
For whatever reason, I got three containers of extra crunchy. Ugh. I have used the Teddie smooth with Flax seed and it's really one of the best I have ever tried and was looking forward to trying their standard peanut butter. I did see if it was possible to deal with the extra crunchy before asking for a refund, and I can tell you it is crunchy. For me, this was a horrible development but maybe not so for everyone.
The silver lining is that I can absolutely recommend the Teddie extra crunchy peanut butter for people who literally like big pieces of peanut in their peanut butter. For the texture, it was still surprisingly consistent and not overly oily. Which, to me is really good.
I did get a refund eventually - though it was very frustrating. But it's really silly to rate the product or the experience ultimately poorly since, as an extra crunchy peanut butter goes, this may be one of the best - and finally I got the mess of the refund settled.
The silver lining is that I can absolutely recommend the Teddie extra crunchy peanut butter for people who literally like big pieces of peanut in their peanut butter. For the texture, it was still surprisingly consistent and not overly oily. Which, to me is really good.
I did get a refund eventually - though it was very frustrating. But it's really silly to rate the product or the experience ultimately poorly since, as an extra crunchy peanut butter goes, this may be one of the best - and finally I got the mess of the refund settled.
Page 1 of 2
Related products

Atkins Endulge Chocolate Peanut Candies, Dessert Favorite, 0g Sugar, 20 Counts
List: $38.27$34.44DEAL






