I purchase these for my French bulldogs she's 11 years old and is missing some teeth. The cookie is great and it smells delicious. It's a little hard for her to chew. Takes her a while. But I definitely would recommend

Most of the treats were broken and in pieces. Are these Seconds!!!!

Who knew dogs like turkey and cranberries? Mine goes wild for these and knows exactly what time he gets his treats and will not let me forget! Even on a road trip thru time zones he still knows when it is treat time. If I try to substitute he will eat the others but still expects to get these and won't leave me alone till he gets these. He has a sensitive stomach but no issues with these. Stools stay normal and he stays happy. Very high values treat.

I'm sad to have to add this edit to the Three Dog Bakery treats. The last 2 orders of these in Aug of 22 were rock hard and I could barely get a knife through them to cut them in half for my little Maltese. I ended up giving them to the neighbor's pit bull. I'm not able to find them anywhere else nearby so I don't know if it's an Amazon storage problem or a bakery change/problem. But I won't be buying these any more.

My Boxers loved them, my YorkiePoo loved them, my Maltese loves them and my daughter's Spitz and Chocolate Lab love them! I started looking for a softer, more flavorful treat for my elderly Boxers a few years ago and found these in a specialty dog store. Mr. Bruno & Mr. Howard sniffed them and chomped them right down. Ms. Tinkerbelle, who was terribly picky about her food & treats sniffed, rejected, sniffed and then inhaled hers. All three of them have passed on now but I have a little elderly Maltese rescue (Cotton) who has horrible teeth that can't be pulled until he's free of heart worms (ugh!). I cut them in half for him & he manages them just fine. I tried other soft treats for him but he won't touch them.
These are not squishy soft but firm yet pliable and easily chewed. They have a nice aroma of the turkey/cranberry or apple or peanut butter ingredients. I keep them in an airtight container as they will begin to lose their softness if left in the container they arrive in. BUT my daughter loves these containers to hold craft items for her small children and Lego pieces that have become separated from the project (Hmmm).
I used these to train my Boxers and now to train little Cotton to come when called and stay in place. My daughter's dogs know where the treats are kept and when they come in from a potty break, they go straight to the treat place and sit, waiting for me to offer them one.
I'm glad to have found these and hope Amazon continues to carry them as they are difficult to find elsewhere.

Great price, my girl loved them