These are great. My dog needs one out at all times. I've started buying them in the bigger bag since it's a little cheaper that way. If he finishes the whole thing he cries at the cabinet until he gets another one. He will chew on them for hours or just guard it so the other animals can't have it. And because it's not a rawhide I don't have to worry when he swallows the last little bit of it. I know he will digest and pass it no problems. I've been ordering these for years and they're a hit in my house. These ones are 12 inches long, but they also make six inch ones for smaller dogs. (I have a pug and he needs the 12 inch ones). The only downside is that they smell terrible to me! When I open the bag and get a whiff it's gross, but the dog loves the flavor. However you can't smell the individual one that he is chewing on. Also they make my dog very thirsty so make sure you have water available for you pet while he chews on his treat :) Been ordering these for about 3 years now and I've never had an issue with quality.

FIRST, let me preface that I would have given one star if it were not for the price of $39/25 sticks because this brand SMELLS REALLY BAD!!!! I can't tell if I just received a bad batch, but my hand still stinks from touching one of the sticks...I just sent an inquiry about the smell and request for exchange... Second, though I understand that these are natural and that naturally penises vary in size....the actual product does not look like the picture. The size of the bully sticks vary significantly in size, with several of them being really skinny (good for miniature dogs) and pretty much like a dog Pocky stick. Since the title says "Supreme," I guess I was expecting a minimum size, or at least sorted by size like other brands. I won't be buying this brand again because I just can't handle the stink and the trouble it is to return/exchange.

For some reason my dogs prefer bully sticks, and it has to be this brand. There is only one other treat that they like as much, or more, and it is not this same brand or item, so I will refrain from commenting on what it is. But I have tried other suppliers' bully sticks, and they are much more quickly to turn down the other brands. They will always take this brand.

All bully sticks are over-priced (my opinion). My animals are the female weighs around 125 and the male is twice her weight around 250 pounds. So the little 6" last about 5 minutes on a good day. The 12" for the same price, last longer, and more the proper size, but heck, if I feed one a day, and there are 6 of the 12" they are gone, and I will be ordering them once a week. And $35-40 week is a bit too much, when I feed them meat with very little dog food every day. They are an ancient breed that requires mostly meat.

But as far as this brand, it is the one to go for. They love it. The price is in line with the price of all bully sticks. They arrive in a timely manner, and the quality is consistent. What more could you ask for?

The smell when I opened the shipping box was terrible! I mean terrible. Thankfully there was nothing else in the box. The package I received had a hole in the bottom. I considered not worrying about it because the expiration date isn't until late 2018, but between the smell and look of these bully sticks I decided to return them.

The bully sticks I received were of small to medium diameter and looked to be "well done." I saw this on a few of the other reviews as well. It just seems brittle and like they could splinter fairly easy. I might have tried them out anyways, but did I mention the smell. I'm telling you, these smell horrible.

This is a new brand for me and I actually purchased pig ears and some shin bones of the same brand at the same time. I received those and the packages were fine. The ears look a little "well done" but I will give them a try. I've purchased way nicer bully sticks in the past so, unless the ears and shin bones turn out to be superb quality, I probably wont buy these again.

Just a side note, initially i requested a replacement from Amazon, but they said since these were from a 3rd party seller, they could only refund my money and send me a shipping label.

I just got my new puppy and I ordered my previous dog's favorite treat, bully sticks. They usually have an odor but these literally stunk up my whole house. If you have a large dog that can eat these outside quickly they may be ok for you but your dogs breath will stink for quite some time. Honestly, I don't know for sure but this is a smell of rotting flesh. I can not conceive how any part of the animal besides its bowels could smell this bad, especially a tendon. If I am wrong please post a response and correct me. In the past some bully sticks would have about 10% of this same odor. Maybe all bully sticks smell this bad and some are treated to different degrees to reduce odor. Regardless, if you have a puppy or small breed who is going to be knawing on these for a long time in the house you may want to reconsider. I live in Milwaukee and it is a similar odor to a leather tannery - and that odor is from rotting animal hides. You can also get bully sticks with no odor but who knows what yhey use to take the odor away.