I will admit I was nervous about buying something like this online. There are things I like to try on first and gloves are on the list. My fears are laid to rest, at least for now. I am ever so happy with these.
I got the red ones since my coats and jackets are black I thought it would make a nice contrast. They are a lovely shade of burgandy.
I have small hands. If I had nails, they would fit perfectly. The middle finger is long on every pair I've ever had and these are no exception, but much closer than most. What this boils down to is that the sizing guide and is accurate but past experience is sometimes a better guide.
I chose the cashmere lining. Fleece gets so hot and you really can't clean it. Plus it often makes your gloves bulky.
And they smell wonderful even after a month. The description didn't exaggerate there, either.
The only thing I can in good conscience nick them for is that the buttons are decorative rather than functional. I wish they actually buttoned. Since the gloves are a bit on the long side I really thought they would. It would make for a better fit.
As it is, they'll stretch out and be less comfortable sooner since leather like this tends to stretch over time.
I'll have to see how they wear. If the lifespan is less than it should be I'll be back.
I do hope this is helpful to someone.

Almost perfect; they are super stylish, cozy soft and warm BUT they say size 7 fits MOST but I have *smaller hands than MOST and felt I should order a half size larger (which, I did), a 7.5 and ... they fit my hands very snug except at the finger tips. At the finger tips they are longer and do not fit to the tips of my fingers making it difficult to use during texting/doing anything on my electronic phone; so, the style is wrong for my hands for using during phone use but they are perfect for style with appears and for keeping my hands warm. I bought the *fleece-lining* It is soft and warm. (7.5 size would prob fit better on slender hands with medium to long-length fingers). I might order another pair, a size 7, to see if they fit my slender but short and stubby fingers better BUT the 7.5 is snug for me to even get my hands into, so, wondering if the cut-style just isn't right for my hands.

Let me start by saying I have long fingers and a lot of arthritis in my hands, particularly in the thumb. I have rarely found a pair of women's leather gloves that fit, even the XL sizes. If I am able to get them on, it is usually a painful process. While I can get into men's gloves, they aren't flattering if one is wearing them with a nice leather or dressy jacket. I saw these and read a lot of reviews before ordering them. I got a size 8.5 and am very pleased with them. I have only worn them a few times, but they are relatively easy to get on (causing only minimal thumb pain). They are pretty warm...I was wearing them in 15 degree weather last week (not for an extended period...about 15 minutes) and my hands stayed warm. The reason I didn't give them five stars is that the fingers are still just a wee bit short, but I am hoping they will stretch a bit. I'm not sure about the durability as I have not had them long, but they seem to be made well. If you have the same type of issues I do, (and I know a LOT of women do) then you may want to consider these gloves.

I'm going to give these gloves four stars mainly due to fit and warmth capabilities.

The gloves themselves are absolutely beautiful. The leather is soft. I'm talking buttery soft. I absolutely adore that. The lining is fairly soft as well, however the gloves are fairly thin.

They would probably work in weather that is a bit warmer than my climate (Central WI) but they lose heat almost immediately when I walk outside. HOWEVER they do protect my hands (mostly) from the biting chill of my steering wheel, which is the main reason I bought them. They also protect me from any wind that hits y hands as I'm pumping gas, etc.

My main beef with these gloves however is the fit. I wear a ring size 7 and so I ordered an 8. My hands are a bit snug but that's fine, I know I have flatter/wide palms. The finger sleeves themselves are too short. The seam at the knuckles comes to about halfway between my knuckles and first joint. It makes it uncomfortable to use the gloves in moments that require more dexterity.

The touchscreen pads work great though. I've had no issues and my phone is very responsive. So far the quality is good, and the packaging was quite lovely.

I ordered the gloves in navy blue, The leather is very soft as is the lining. They are not at all bulky but I think the lining is thick enough that they will provide some meaningful warmth. The blue is very dark--almost black. Once on my hands, the gloves fit quite well. However, the opening is very small and because of the button cuff detail, which results in the leather being doubled across half the glove, there is very little give to the leather. It was a struggle to get the gloves on over the bottom joint of my thumb. Once on, the fit was very good so it wasn't a case of them being the wrong size. I hope they stretch because it's not really practical to have gloves that take a minute to wriggle in to. Overall, they are good gloves, but the color is a bit off (seriously, I wasn't at all sure they were blue, not black) and the design makes them really tough to get on, so they only get 4 stars.