As someone who has purchased and consumed this product for the last 2-3 years, I must say that it is delicious and nutritious. I love peanut butter and PB flavored almost everything. This cookie butter is the best of the flavors, in my opinion, however if you like Nutella, I would recommend their hazelnut chocolate flavor, it's Devine.

I keep this in my pantry and have mini anxiety attacks when I notice it getting close to empty. It's packed full of protein and easier to spread than most peanut butter. Additionally, it pairs well with apple slices, French toast, protein pancakes, regular toast, and almost anything you can think of. Even decatant by itself on a spoon. I wouldn't waste putting it in a shake since that would take away and dilute the taste of this awesome spread. Just mix well when first opening it. Don't hesitate to try it, you'll thank me!

This review is for the Birthday Cake flavor. I have to say I was skeptical because peanut butter is such a strong flavor, it's hard to make it taste like something more subtle like vanilla cake but I'm extremely surprised to say they did it & they did it well. When I opened the container I noticed immediately there were sprinkles which are pretty but I hate them. Fortunately, I didn't mind them at all!

I used a low calorie wrap and spread about two tablespoons of Birthday Cake on it then added fresh sliced strawberries & felt like I was eating a guilt free strawberry shortcake! I highly recommend this product & I will be trying the other flavors as well.

I could tell from the smell while I was opening the package the flavor was going to be weird. Very sweet and fake tasting. Texture was extremely grainy. Also should have paid attention but the macros aren't that great especially for "healthy" peanut butter 11g fat/12g carbs/11g protein - 179 cal/serving versus Skippy natural 16g fat/6g carbs/7g protein -190 cal/serving.
I have tried PB2 and that isn't bad.. but probably protein peanut butter is a waste of money. Save yourself some money and just but regular natural peanut butter.
2 stars bc the jar is pretty at least.

I have tried a few others in this brand that I like and I also have tried a Birthday Cake flavor from Buff Bake which is an Almond Spread and it was okay. I am always hesitant to try new ones cuz I don't wanna spend this much money and not like it but a friend of mine said no, this Birthday one is the best! So I gave it a shot and it's now my new favorite! For a protein spread, it's honestly super good and really does have a birthday cake flavor. I will definitely order this many more times and I wish I could just eat the jar in one sitting with a spoon.

Love this stuff. Got some oily weird stuff from "shipped fast" but anything from Nuts N More or Amazon has been great. Birthday cake and toffee crunch are the best flavors.

Edit: Ordered again. Consistency must be weather related. These were an oily mess. The trick is to get it so you can stir it... Stir it (the birthday cake pieces are on the bottom)...Then put it in the fridge. You can then eat it from the fridge or put it out to soften up again. After remixing (which you shouldn't have to do) it's fine.