Glad to give these boots a second chance. I like the boots and price was good.

They are a snug fit, but a great shoe. I decided to return and size up. They are tight around the top of the foot and ankle.

I'm really wanting to love these, but have had challenges finding the right fit. The quality seems good; I think the tread is going to be helpful in wet conditions; I like the overall shape, ankle height & general comfort. Still to be determined how they perform in active rainy/wet conditions over the long-run. My sizing issues: I normally wear a 9.5 Women's (up from 8.5 in my young adult years, due to flattening/widening & big toe arthritis/intermittent foot swelling); my foot just barely reaches a 10" length; I first ordered a Bogs 10 (based on reviews and as I wanted to be able to slip on as close to hands-free as possible. The 10's required hands, but felt cozy at first; after wearing them around the house for a while, I noticed a snugness gradually putting excessive pressure on my feet. They are a decent length, but not loose enough for anything but brief uses for sensitive medium+ wide feet. So, I ordered the next size up, Bogs 11; definitely no hands needed, but very loose. Since my main goal is comfort, dryness and hands-free, I decided to keep wearing the 11's, though they are definitely too large and I could REALLY USE A HALF SIZE between these two. I've warn the 11's outside on errands twice, and incidentally the stitching on the back finger loop on one of the boots has broken - and I haven't even used the loop since they are plenty loose for hands-free donning. Urgh. Would probably give 5 stars if they had half sizes and the loop wasn't broken.

Pros:
- Seem like good quality (except the broken loop); long term durability to be determined.
- Good tread
- Comfortable neoprene type lining/ankle-surround
- Adequately comfortable insoles (not necessarily for long walks... TBD)
- If you have a somewhat narrow foot and wear 9.5 normally, the 10's might work for you. (but not for a foot that's even just a little wide).

Cons:
- Skewed sizing system -- they run SMALL
- No half size options
- Large difference between the sizes (about 1" between the 10's and 11's) - may not be possible to find the right fit
- Finger loop on ankle detaching already without any direct use on one of mine

Roomy easy to put on and easy cleanup after mowing or working on garden etc.

You can't slip these on, you have to grasp them and the tab on the back is to small. Overall kind of a pain to get on.