I have owned a elite and infinity 1 scuf. I bought this to play cod and have used it daily for a week. I would say for me this is best. The first reason is the button placement on the back (I did have to put a piece of masking tape for better grip on it). The scuf is too hard to press, although It does get looser. The elite I press by mistake to much, but has the fastest response.
Next the bumpers on it respond noticeable faster. I don't notice any differ between all 3 controller on the triggers. I like the trigger stops built in something the elite doesn't have.
The main reason I bought this is my elite joysticks were wore out. I've it about 1.5 years play with it almost daily. It is still a good choice.

Other things to know. Like all new controller they joysticks has to we broken in. I started on a 10 sensitive and am now back down to my normal 5 after a week. My aim seems better, but time will tell.

If you play with kontrol freeks the ps3/Xbox 360 work great.

Hands down the best Xbox Controller I've used. I purchased the Elite controller about a year ago and could not get used to the extra paddles. I gave up on it and just went back to the normal controller. I purchased the Razer Wolverine Ultimate just to try it but fell in love. The placement of the extra bumper buttons near the triggers are perfect. In playing halo it made switching weapons seamless. Of course, you can assign them to be whatever buttons you see fit. Mine were reload and switch. The extra bumpers are located more inward than the elite so you can almost play without noticing them. They do offer some added benefits though, one being the focus button. It's great for snipers. The XYBA buttons are also more mouse like in their clicks. Super enjoyable. The only reason I give it 4 stars is because it has no wireless functionality. I feel like an option should be there.

Razer Wolverine Ultimate

Great controller , feels sturdy and built well. the performance compare to Elite Controller is way better . I like the mechanical keys , they are so easy to press and always pressed not like the reguler sometimes they not . all the buttons are similiar to the Elite Controller which is great cause I wanted the same feel of elite but with better feedback and better analog sticks because the Elite have big issue with the analogs. need to calibrate them because they are not 100% straight which makes the dead zone really effect the movement when you move to either side and lift your finger the stick would move to the other side making another movement in the game... 2 controllers that I bought same issue. never had issue with normal ps3 or ps4 controllers and also this razer . so it's something with the elite that annoyed me. the windows 10 is great . even better than the elite xbox app. all settings there.

overall razer made great unbeatable controller.

I have owned a SCUF One, the Microsoft Elite Contoller, and now the Razer Wolverine Ultimate and I can honestly say this has become my favorite controller.

I cannot speak bad about the SCUF other than the fact my paddles kept breaking and I had to replace them often. It wasn't major, but it was annoying. Even still, the SCUF ranks better than the Elite being that I had it for over 2 years with HEAVY use (Destiny, Halo 5) and the only issue was the paddles breaking over time.

The reason I upgraded to the Elite is because I wanted to move from 2 paddles to 4. The Elite fit the bill, and I did not have to wait for my controller to be made, I was able to hit a local GameStop and pick one up that day.
Initially I was excited, but I've had pretty much every known problem with my Elite. My left bumper broke (search for elite bumper repair kit"”-its so common that multiple sellers have repair kits for the bumpers!), my sticks became very loose (inexcusable considering I had the SCUF more than twice as long and never experienced that issue), and the grip panels on the controller began to peel"”so annoying that I finally just removed them altogether. I bought the controller in april of 2017 and while it was still usable when I purchased the Razer in Jan "˜18, I would NOT say the quality was at all worth the price tag. The SCUF FAR surpassed the Elite in this category.

Now for the Wolverine Ultimate.
So far I can tell you that this is my favorite controller. I can't speak for the durability or quality over time yet, but the controller FEELS like it's actually going to last. I will update my review at different intervals and update on this.

The buttons are super responsive (light touches to the ABXY buttons will active them), and they feel more like a mouse click than the squishy feeling you get from the regular Xbox controllers (Elite and even SCUF included being that it uses the body of a regular one controller)

The hair triggers work as well or better than the offering on the Elite, and I do prefer them over the Hair Trigger Lock system my SCUF One used. I'm not sure if Scuf has made improvements in this area with their newer controller (Infinity?) but even the Elite controller was preferable to what was on my Scuf. The Wolverine pretty much exactly the way the Elite does, and it does decrease the trigger travel a great deal.

NOTE: I did NOT have issues with the hair triggers being a problem like I did with my Scuf and even elite (I had to calibrate the triggers being in hair trigger mode using the software on Xbox). So far I have played PUBG and Halo 5. Some games need the trigger to travel more than some hair trigger systems allow to register (thus it needing to be calibrated for the Elite"”no option for this on the SCUF OR Wolverine). Once again, though, I have had no issue with the Wolverine not registering on a game yet.

The top paddles I thought would be an adjustment"”but other than retraining my brain, they are very easy and "natural" to use. The bottom 4 are excellently placed and are quite easy to access using your middle and ring ringers, eliminating the need for your fingers to ever leave the sticks. I have opted to use the default buttton mapping (X and Y On left and right top paddles, A and B on the first 2 of 4 bottom paddles, and the using the bottom left paddle for FOCUS And the bottom right for AGILE).

I'm not going to explain to you what FOCUS and AGILE do because that's available to you elsewhere, just know that once you get used to the controller and the idea of having it"”it is a game changer! More precision or speed as you need it at your fingertips? Yes please.

If you're alrwady considering this controller this should be a sign that you should give it a try.

I decided to because I used a Razer copperhead Mouse when I PC gamed back when dinosaurs still roamed the earth (Quake 2), and was always very happy with it. I'm glad I decided to try the Wolverine, it has not disappointed yet.

(Side note- I did have the elite controller before but felt to bulky for me. Paddles did feel cheap on it.)

However, this is such Good alternative to the regular & elite controller.
The RGB lights are very thorough & the ergonomics on the controller feel very good in your hands.
The buttons do feel solid with every click.
One feature I did wish this controller would of for the price tag is wireless. You would expect a controller over 100$ to at least have wireless.
I have not tryed this on PC but I Definitely do recommend this for xbox gamers out there !

Note this are initial thoughts. Let's see if this will last.