I'm usually not sure about ordering clothing, but I did order this for my husband and it fit him wonderfully. It's heavy enough to stay warm but not too heavy you're uncomfortable. The flannel is very warm.

I live in the Atlanta, Georgia area, and this jacket has proven to be a good all winter jacket for me. Temps at and just above freezing with mild winds are our normal cold. It remains comfortable to wear in the 40s to low 50s F (5 - 13 C) if I'm not overly active.

Fit wise:
I got a medium, and the fit of the jacket is about as good as any for me without getting something tailored. I'm 6'4" at 175 lbs - tall and thin - 91 in (231 cm) arm span (finger tip to finger tip.) I have to compromise on the fit of most clothes, and I have tried on a large Carhartt jacket before, and it's just too large for me in both the waist and chest. The medium is slightly larger than I want in the waist, but the chest is good. The problem for me is the arms are a little short, but I expected that, and they are not overly short, and I'm used to that type of fit. It's only when I fully bend my arms that the jacket rides up and exposes a part of my arm.

Overall the jacket is comfortable and I like the way it looks.

First off, I'm 6"2 at 207 and I ordered a large after reading about them running large. I wish there was a "Medium Tall" or every size + "Tall" because I'm still swimming in the chest area but wish it was just an inch longer on the arms and torso. So to clarify this, its a perfect fit if you aren't extending your arms (working/etc) and just keeping it casual, with the exception of the chest area. I would be worried about a medium being too short everywhere but I'm sure the chest would fit great.

Quality is definitely there. I don't feel at all like this is getting ruined this century. This thing is TOUGH! The lining is super soft and warm as well. If you are just hanging around or doing office work it's great. If you start moving or getting active it heats up like you wouldn't believe. I have zero doubts you would be cold if you were working/active in 20-30 degree weather with just a t-shirt on under it. Hood very comfy and fits well.

I've heard you can rub (and then work) a candle/wax on this type of outer canvas/cotton material and use it to make it fully waterproof. I think that will be what I do next.

Bonus fact: Pet fur, cat in my case, is drawn to this jacket.

I had been wanting a Carhartt jacket for a while. My fiance' wanted to buy me one for my birthday a few months ago while it was still cold here inTexas, but we couldn't find one in my size in the stores at the time so she got me something else. A few weeks ago, I received an email from amazon about a sale on the same jacket I was interested in and it was 30% off retail price. As usual, I did my homework and looked at reviews extensively as well as other jacket styles. I almost went with a lighter weight jacket, but glad I didn't, as I have several ligh weight jackets already. The reviews seemed to all suggest the jacket runs large so, I ordered a medium as I am 5'11" 170 lbs. and normally a large in jackets. I'm glad I did because the medium fits near perfectly. I'm sure the large would be way too bulky on me. If I fully extend my arms over my head, the jacket does expose my stomach a bit and the cuffs do ride up my wrists slightly, however this is to be expected and happens with my other, large sized jackets as well. I'm sure that in extreme cold climates, you would want to go for your normal size so the jacket could be worn over multiple layers, but for me in Texas, I feel this jacket will keep my warm with only a single layer underneath on the coldest of days.

Carhartt products are no longer made in the USA, however the fabric used does still come from US providers. The construction seems very sturdy. The jacket is a bit stiff, but after one wash, it is a bit more loose. I was looking for a rugged jacket and this fits the bill. I expect this jacket will hold up through the roughest situations and last many years. I love the quilted lining, it is very comfortable. The arms are quilted as well, but not with flannel like the rest of the jacket. This is designed to let you get your arms through even while wearing a long sleeve shirt underneath. The inner pockets are a great feature and while the outer pockets aren't lined, they are spacious and comfortable enough for hands. The zipper is very rugged and takes a little persuasion sometimes, as expected from a heavy-duty zipper. The hood is spacious and comfortable. It does add some bulk just behind the neck, but I'd rather have it there if needed than not. It does have pull strings to fit more snugly if needed. The arms and waist have elastic bands to keep out any drafts when it is windy and they are just as heavy-duty as the rest of the jacket.

Overall, I am very satisfied with this jacket. I haven't worn it besides trying it on a few times yet, but I don't imagine I'll change my mind when I do.

bought this for my ex when we were still together, as an x.mas present. He loved it.