My rating is particular to the fit for ME, not a commentary on the quality - this shoe is amazingly constructed, looks classy on, and for leather, you can't beat the price. Stitching and gluework was excellent. While I agree that sizing up half a size would be great for those with broader feet, I also agree that you should get your normal size because even wearing these for 15 minutes, I saw that they were malleable and probably fit better with time.

My specific issue is that with narrow feet, the toebed is wonderful, but if you ALSO have no arch, you have to tie the laces at the absolute tightest they go - so for me, it would be too large in the ankle opening and where the leather comes together in tying. Too bad for me, because these would be perfect otherwise! But if you've a low clearance in terms of the 'height' of your foot, these probably won't work for you. It's not the sole width that is the issue, but the shoe height.

Love, Love, Love these shoes! Happy I ordered them! I get compliments on the ALL the time!

Love them. I've been searching for oxfords that would fit me for the longest time and am glad I stumbled upon these. I love the color and the look. They are a little bit tight and I have to kind of force my foot into them, but that's because I have large, wide feet. I expect it will get easier once they're more broken in. I will probably buy these shoes in black.

Good looking and comfortable. But the seam broke in the first week.

Haven't worn these yet because they're smaller than I expected so I'm exchanging them. They seem comfy expect tight at the toes. No big deal. This review is for the question and others wondering what the difference between these and the $89 ones is. These cheaper ones are a bit bulkier, darker, less slim, are one flat color, and have a bit taller heel. The $89 ones are slimmer, overall sleeker, lighter with the color getting a tad darker towards the toe and heel, the heel is a bit shorter, and the broguing differs too. They both seem nice to me and I plan to keep them both once exchanged; the darker for casual and lighter for more dressier occasions. My only complaint besides the tightness in the toes (but I don't wear tight shoes anyway so it could just be me) is the dull color on the $89 ones. I plan to polish them to a nicer tan with a hint of orange. Hope this helps! :)