This review is strictly on the product. Great product. Fits well. Kept my husbands feet dry in NYC during the big snowstorm walking a little over 10.5 miles. No pain, rubbing or anything.
Now either the company or amazon screwed up. I ordered these and should have had them in 2 days.. the didn't ship them out until 4 days after I purchased. Then we had a storm (which is why I wanted them and should have had them a few days before the storm). It ever up taking almost 2 weeks to get.

Positive: Got these boots for my son in law and he used them all winter while shoveling. He really said he liked them.
Negative: one of the eyelets came out when he tightened laces. Not sure if his fault or the boot.

I really like these boots. I haven't had a chance to truly test them out, but they are comfortable, seem to be sufficiently warm and water proof and look nice. I believe the fit is true to size, that being said, I returned the first pair I ordered for a half size larger, just for a bit more room around the toe box. The 8's I originally ordered wouldn't have been roomy enough to my liking if I decided to wear thicker socks. The 8 1/2's that I eventually received instead felt much better.

I don't wear boots everyday, I have an office job, but when my Timberlands wore out, I was shopping for them. I saw these and thought the price was so good in comparison that it was worth trying out. The quality is really, really good. They great for the snow. If anything they are overinsulated. In 20 degree weather my feet are almost sweating. Soles are strudy and all the seams holding good. When I wear them its all day. So its not just to go outside and playin the snow for an hour. I have worn them all day several times and they are just as good as first day...Great bang for the buck! If the goal is water proof boot for cold weather...look no further.

I got these for around 20.00 shipped and I've put them through 2 fairly demanding hikes. Once in ankle-high water (Table Mountain after rains) and once in slush/snow (Ralston Peak).

They came out water logged on the inside on my Table Mountain hike, only because water had seeped in from the top (not from the sides). They came out bone dry on the inside from the Ralston hike where I had to tread through both slush and snow. I was very pleased!

They are very warm. The fuzzies at the top definitely help to add to the warm factor. The sole is flocked, which again helps no just in increasing comfort but warmth.

So far, there are no foreseeable durability issues. Nothing is broken yet lol. I plan on Mt Shasta and Mt Whitney in these.

---
That they've held up to 2 fairly rigorous hikes is inspiring a lot of confidence in these. I'm so happy with these I bought another pair.