Four stars for a 1911R, but five stars for a P22X...

This is a quality made leather holster at a reasonable price. I originally bought it for my railed 1911 (description says it would fit) and while it did fit, I wasn't happy for two reasons. First, on a 5" 1911, about 1/2" extended out the bottom of the holster. I prefer to not have the muzzle extend out of an open bottom holster. Second is that while the 1911 was nice and snug, no worries for retention, it did allow some front to rear rotational movement if you put front or rear pressure on the gun.

The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is that while it is marketed for a railed 1911, it doesn't quite work for mine to my satisfaction. I am sure other would be happy with the fit on a 1911 but I can be a little "OCD" about these things. I would have given it a 4.5 if I could and had I bought it specifically for my P226 or a P220, it would be a five star rating.

I ended up ordering a Desantis holster for my 1911 and while it has a more custome fit, the 1791 uses a thicker and more substantial leather.

Even though I wasn't looking for a leather holster for my Sig Legion P226, I will keep this one because it fits the P226 like a glove, no movement, and completely covers the muzzle.

Hard to find a decent leather holster these days at a reasonable price and even harder to find one that you don't have to wait weeks if not months to receive.

I hope 1791 is able to increase their catalogue of custom fit holsters, would love to have one of these for some of my other handguns.

Buy it and see why it's my favorite. OK, it does take at least 24 hours to get the 'perfect' fit, but it's so worth it. The instructions call for a thick freezer bag - that's what I used, but had to keep repeating and let it sit for 24 hours each time. Now, I have one of the best holster I've ever used and it's perfect.The leather doesn't wear on the PVD finish of my Legion like the Kydex does and it feels more secure at the same time. And the quality - WOW! Every stitch is perfect, all seams are spectacular. I looks like a holster made by someone who is used to making custom saddles.

I've never had a leather holster that was so well made for such a low price. To me, it's easily worth twice the price. 1791 cares - I can see that in their craftsmanship. If you have a P226 and are on the fence, let this be your push - get it!

I am very particular about OWB holsters. Not a kydex kind of guy so I prefer leather holsters especially for steel framed firearms. I had been shopping for Sig friendly holsters. Must have looked seriously at at least 25 different brands from custom made ones to the expected commercial mass offerings. This one caught my eye and I am completely happy with what I received from 1791 Leather. Out of the Amazon box this holster shined with quality. The leather was first rate- sturdy, solid and well stitched. Its design was intriguing overall and I appreciated the "curve" made into the holster so it rides close to the hip. At 3 o'clock it rides solid and gives easy access for presentations. I did take the time to break it in as I do with leather holsters. Rubbed in some leather lotion into the outside and used some "quick draw" treatment to the inside. Holstered the unloaded firearm inside a plastic freezer bag for about 48 hours. After 24 hours I reapplied the lotions, let them dry and reholstered the firearm. The result was an altogether unbelievable holster. I also drew and reholstered the empty firearm a number of times still in the plastic freezer bag to do a final check for fit and retention. I eventually put the holster on my belt and wore it for several hours. It is a KEEPER! Love the dark brown color too. Very happy I chose it. I am 100% certain that anyone who wants a quality holster and doesn't want to spend twice the money will be as pleased with this 1791 holster as I am. It's an heirloom holster I will treasure. Thanks 1791!!! You folks are doing a great service to those of us who want holsters.

This is a very well constructed holster. The leather is THICK and sewn with nice even, heavy stitching. Unlike most pancake style holsters, this holster is molded with a curve to better fit the shape of your hip. The molded belt slots have been molded (bent) for the shape of the hip, is 3/8" thick! I usually don't buy pancake holsters because the tighter you cinch your belt, results in more pressure on the back of your gun. That makes it difficult to withdraw your weapon, or even holster it! This holster is curved so the pressure on the back of your gun is greatly relieved, reducing that problem!
One option that I wish they would offer is a safety strap over the hammer with a steel thump break, similar to Bianchi's. I have some (somewhat matching color) leather and will make my own. The other feature I would be willing to pay extra for is soft leather lining. Lacking that, try wrapping your weapon in several layers of saran wrap and give the inside of your holster a couple coats (let dry between coats) of Gum Tragacanth, the inside of the holster will be slick as... (from Tandy Leather) AND the seller also sent a useful complimentary gift!!

As other reviews stated, the quality and craftsmanship are obvious. Before it arrived, was concerned about whether it would fit both Sigs, or if it would be too tight and need a lot of massaging to make it work. Both the 229 and 226 fit perfectly: snug, but not too tight. Because of my work (lots of movement, bending, stretching, getting in and out of vehicles, etc.), wanted a holster that would not let go of my semi (unless I wanted it to do so). This holster appears to meet that need. Also, keeps the gun close to my side, but not uncomfortably. Does anyone know why the name "1791"?