I normally wear 7 3/8 and can wear 7 1/2 if needed. I ordered a charcoal Large. It is a full 7 5/8. I tried wearing it but it ended up resting on my ears. Also, the crown was a too roomy and felt like I was wearing a bucket. Thus, I decided to try a Medium.

Based on what I normally wear, I would put the Medium at a 7 1/4 or maybe 7 5/16. It's a little snug on me and whereas I can't stand a tight hat, I decided to keep the Medium and return the Large. I trust it will stretch a bit and become comfortable. It does have an elastic band that I'm hoping will loosed up with time. And, the Medium isn't a headache maker; rather, I'll say it would be good in a strong wind. On the other hand, if you have a small head, there's no way a Medium is going to fit.

As for the form of the cap, I like it. It's a crush'able-structured crown. It doesn't have the hardened crosshatch stuff found in the crown of structured caps. On the other hand, it's not floppy like a traditional unstructured cap. Rather, it's similar to a crush'able Stetson, perhaps a little less formed and definitely softer.

It is indeed very warm and I do like it. It's just that the sizing is a little nuts. Also, it does a good job covering your ears and neck. I've tried other brands that just barely cover your ears. This one does a good job.

Nice hat great replacement to my old one. Only complaint is that it is a little loose but otherwise very happy

I was disappointed that the fur was just at the fold down but the receiver was more than happy with the lining, construction and fit. He figured once he broke it in, the outside bill points wouldn't dig into his forehead. Now all he needs is some Red Green suspenders .

24% wool with a polyester lining. Very comfortable but runs slightly on the small side. The flaps will not cover your earlobes unless you really pull the cap down hard on your noggin but I would buy again.

Reasonably comfortable and I like the ear flaps. Good value for the price.