Pretty good replica, though the size chart is definitely off. I went with what should have been a much bigger size, but it ended up fitting just right, to the point where my son will outgrow it within a year. The other thing I don't like is that the back side of the top slopes back, so trying to attach a replacement strap is a bit of a challenge, because the conical top will make the strap "ride up."

Not bad for the price though, and my son loves it.

Overall it's fair for the price point. Don't expect a super plush western style Stetson. It's perfect for Halloween or for a few time use.

Please read this:
"I am a western, Outlaw style country Singer. I am also extremely picky when it comes to quality. Based on the sizing chart provided, I went with the XL in ordering both a Black and Brown hat - they fit perfectly! I got both colors to match whatever I need to wear outfit wise.
I'm really surprised to read some of the low review scores, because I don't know what you all expected for the price??? I dig that this hat is all leather, and even that they are made in Mexico - which brings more nostalgia to the early Clint Eastwood spaghetti western movie vibe (though they were actually filmed in Spain). This is quality rough leather, and I have zero regrets!! I bought two for the same price of what just one of some of these felt hats cost on Amazon that don't even look as cool! Forget the frills that you often see in some cowboy hats that are too ornate and over the top! Get this bad-ass hat that fits what we all imagine the old west to have been." Bob

A really nice hat, not quite what I was expecting. But nonetheless a really nice hat

It's as close to the one in the movie as you can get for the price. The brim can be as flat or curved as you want. The brim has wire running through it that can be shaped to preference. The leather is really rough but that is a good thing for the look. I removed the hat band and am looking to replace it with a black one to closer match the movie hat. The top of the hat is a little rough as far as the stitching. Can't really tell when facing the hat, but becomes obvious when looking down like in the picture I added. Happy with the purchase and am ready for Halloween.